How to compare unlike bids in procurement

When suppliers quote different scopes, the lowest price is often the smallest scope. Bring every bid to the scope of your tender before you rank them.

Published March 30, 20261 minute read

Unlike bids answer different questions

One supplier includes commissioning, another quotes it separately, a third limits it to five days on site. Each price is correct for what that supplier offered. None of them is the price of what you asked for.

Use your tender as the baseline

List every requirement where a bid falls short of the tender: items not included, items quoted separately, and conditions that limit what is included. Keep the supplier's wording and where it appears for each one.

Two bids at the same scopeData centre cooling upgrade
Tender requirementCoolmarkArctis
Quoted price€1,710,000€1,840,000
15 days of commissioning support

Commissioning support quoted separately.

Coolmark_Commercial_Offer.pdf, page 6
+€42,000Included€0
Spare parts for 2 years

Spare parts not included.

Coolmark_Commercial_Offer.pdf, page 7
+€58,000Included€0
Prices valid for 120 days

Prices are valid for 60 days from submission.

Coolmark_Commercial_Offer.pdf, page 3
Ask120 days
At the tender's scope€1,810,000€1,840,000

+€42,000 Your estimate, not the supplier's quoteAsk: goes into the clarification round

Coolmark is €130,000 cheaper as quoted and €30,000 cheaper once the gaps are priced. Coolmark's 60-day validity can't be priced, so it becomes a clarification question.

Price the gaps you can, ask about the rest

Where a gap has a market price, add your own estimate and mark it as yours, so nobody mistakes it for the supplier's quote. Where it doesn't, such as a short price validity or a liability cap, send a clarification request.

Rank last

Rank the bids once they cover the same scope. The ranking then compares what each supplier offers for the work you tendered, and the estimates behind it are on the record for the award discussion.

Where to go next

Bring one of your own tenders to the demo.

We load the RFQ and a few supplier submissions, and you check the findings against your own documents.

Request a demo