How to compare freight forwarding bids

A rate sheet prices the forwarder's assumptions. Price the bids against your own operation instead: the laytime you need, the container days you use, and the fuel risk you are willing to carry.

Published March 30, 20261 minute read

Start from your operation

Before opening the bids, write down what the shipment needs: free days at each port, container days from discharge to return, permits along the route, and the heaviest lift. These are the numbers every bid gets priced against.

Two freight bids, priced against the operationTurbine retrofit, 40 containers and 2 heavy lifts

7 days laytime at discharge10 days per containerFixed fuel cost for the term

TermBaltica FreightNordhafen Logistics
Rate sheet total€412,000€438,500
Laytime2 days short at €9,500 a day

Free time at discharge: five (5) days.

Baltica_Terms.pdf, section 2
+€19,0007 days€0
Container detention40 containers, 5 days each at €78

Detention charged from day 6.

Baltica_Terms.pdf, page 31
+€15,60010 days€0
Fuel surcharge

BAF adjusted quarterly per index.

Baltica_Rate_Sheet.xlsx, footnote 4
AskFixed for the term€0
Priced against the operation€446,600€438,500

+€19,000 Your estimate, not the supplier's quoteAsk: goes into the clarification round

Baltica Freight is €26,500 cheaper as quoted and €8,100 more expensive once the gaps are priced. That is before any fuel adjustment.

Ask about what you can't price

Some terms have no number yet: a fuel surcharge adjusted every quarter, permits that wait on a route survey, a minimum volume per sailing. Send them as clarification questions and compare the answers before the award.

Read the whole package

Laytime, detention, and surcharges usually sit in the terms and the rate sheet footnotes, not in the transport concept. Read every file for each forwarder, including scanned route surveys.

Where to go next

Bring one of your own tenders to the demo.

We load the RFQ and a few supplier submissions, and you check the findings against your own documents.

Request a demo